Top 3 Disability Insurance Lawyers in Fort Lauderdale (2026)

Fort Lauderdale, Florida · Updated November 2026

Top 3 Disability Insurance Lawyers in Fort Lauderdale (2026)

Three Fort Lauderdale firms that handle denied or delayed disability insurance claims, compared on Google ratings, published focus, buyout and ERISA work, and what clients say. Disability Insurance Law Group is listed first.

  • ✓Long-term disability denials
  • ✓ERISA appeals
  • ✓Lump sum buyouts
  • ✓Individual policies
3Firms compared
357Combined Google reviews
4.7–5.0★Rating range

By the Editorial Team · Ratings checked November 2, 2026

Short answer: For a practice built only around disability, long-term care and life insurance claims, start with Disability Insurance Law Group near Cypress Creek. Victor Peña Law PLLC is a downtown solo practice that publishes buyout and overpayment work. Lawlor, White & Murphey is a long-running personal injury firm that also lists short-term disability and bad faith insurance claims.

At a glance

Fort Lauderdale disability insurance firms compared

FirmGoogle ratingReviewsPublished focusConsultationERISA claimsLump sum buyoutsLong-term care claims
1Disability Insurance Law Group★★★★½ 4.746Disability, long-term care, life and AD&D insuranceFree (per firm)✓✓✓
2Lawlor, White & Murphey★★★★½ 4.9222Personal injury, short-term disability, bad faith insuranceFree (per firm)Call to askCall to askCall to ask
3Victor Peña Law PLLC★★★★★ 5.089Disability insurance onlyFree (per firm)✓✓Call to ask

“Call to ask” means the firm does not publish this on its website.

Ratings and review counts from Google, checked November 2, 2026. Hours can change on holidays; call to confirm.

The list

Top 3 disability insurance lawyers in Fort Lauderdale

1

Disability Insurance Law Group

★★★★½ 4.7 · 46 Google reviews · Cypress Creek area
Free consultationDisability-focused practiceServes Florida and nationwide

Insurance claims handled

  • Long-term disability claims
  • ERISA group policies
  • Individual disability policies
  • Claim denial appeals
  • Lump sum buyouts
  • Long-term care insurance
  • Life insurance and AD&D

Disability Insurance Law Group is a Fort Lauderdale firm whose practice is built around insurance benefit claims: short-term and long-term disability, ERISA group policies, individual disability policies, long-term care, life insurance and accidental death and dismemberment. Attorneys Alicia Paulino Grisham and Mindy L. Chmielarz lead the firm, which states it serves clients across Florida and nationwide and has over 50 years of combined experience handling insurance matters. Its disability page describes help with filing claims, negotiating a lump sum buyout, fighting a denial or delay, and managing a lawsuit for benefits. The firm offers a free consultation.

What clients praise

  • Reviewers describe Mindy Chmielarz as knowledgeable, responsive and calm with nervous first-time callers
  • Several name Alicia Paulino-Grisham and paralegal Nicole Paulino for compassionate, steady support
  • One family credits the firm with a long-term care claim for a parent after earlier denials

Worth knowing

  • One reviewer says follow-up calls and emails went unanswered for over two months after a phone consultation
  • The firm does not publish its fee terms; ask how fees work for monthly benefits versus a buyout
  • Mon–Sun Open 24 hours

Why it made the list: A practice centered on disability and related insurance claims, with ERISA, individual policy, buyout and long-term care work all published.

📞 (954) 989-9000

📍 3201 W Commercial Blvd, Suite 227, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33309

2

Lawlor, White & Murphey

★★★★½ 4.9 · 222 Google reviews · Davie Boulevard, southwest of downtown
Free consultationFounded 1996Español

Insurance and injury matters listed

  • Short-term disability claims
  • Bad faith insurance
  • Personal injury
  • Wrongful death
  • Medical malpractice
  • Hurricane and property claims

Lawlor, White & Murphey is a Fort Lauderdale personal injury firm founded in 1996 by John K. Lawlor, with attorneys including Ben Murphey and Anthony B. White. Its practice list includes short-term disability claims and bad faith insurance alongside accident, malpractice and wrongful death cases, and its short-term disability page explains the difference between short-term and long-term coverage for Broward and Palm Beach County workers. The site has a Spanish-language section and offers a free consultation, and the firm states clients pay nothing until compensation is recovered.

What clients praise

  • Reviewers say the team kept them informed at every step and explained things in plain terms
  • Anthony White and assistant Diana Medina are named for quick, clear answers
  • Several mention the firm's community involvement and fundraising for local causes

Worth knowing

  • Disability work is a small part of a broad injury practice, and its published disability page focuses on short-term claims
  • The reviews we read describe injury cases rather than long-term disability or ERISA appeals, so ask about that experience directly
  • Mon–Sun Open 24 hours

Why it made the list: A long-established Fort Lauderdale firm that lists short-term disability and bad faith insurance claims, useful when an injury and a benefits claim overlap.

📞 (954) 525-2345

📍 2211 Davie Blvd, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33312

3

Victor Peña Law PLLC

★★★★★ 5.0 · 89 Google reviews · Downtown, Broward Boulevard
Free consultationDisability buyoutsServes clients nationwide

Disability matters handled

  • Disability buyouts and settlements
  • Overpayment disputes
  • Monthly claim management
  • Private disability denials
  • ERISA claims

Victor Peña Law PLLC is a disability insurance practice led by attorney Victor Peña, with offices in downtown Fort Lauderdale and Longwood. The firm states it represents claimants nationwide against all major disability insurers, and its site lists disability buyouts and settlements, overpayment notices, monthly claim management and private and ERISA disability denials. Its pages name carriers it deals with, including Unum, Prudential, The Hartford, MetLife and Guardian. The firm offers a free consultation.

What clients praise

  • Reviewers say Victor Peña answers the phone himself and spends real time on the first call
  • Several describe fast results on long-term disability claims and buyout settlements
  • One reviewer credits him with resolving a Prudential overpayment demand after a Social Security award

Worth knowing

  • A solo-led practice; ask who handles the file when the attorney is unavailable
  • Much of the work is done remotely, so confirm whether in-person meetings happen at the downtown office
  • Mon–Sun Open 24 hours

Why it made the list: A disability-only practice with published buyout, overpayment and claim management work, led by an attorney reviewers say is easy to reach.

📞 (954) 475-6038

📍 500 E Broward Blvd, Suite 1710, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33394

Free tool

Which Fort Lauderdale firm fits your claim?

Tick what you need. We match it against each firm's published practice areas.

Tick one or more options to see matching firms.

Guide

How disability insurance claims work in Florida

180 DAYS

Minimum time to appeal an ERISA denial

If your disability coverage comes through a private employer, federal ERISA rules give you at least 180 days to file an internal appeal after a denial. The record built in that appeal usually limits what a court can review later.

45 DAYS

Initial decision window for ERISA disability claims

An ERISA plan generally must decide a disability claim within 45 days, with up to two 30-day extensions if it explains why more time is needed.

5 YEARS

Florida contract deadline for many individual policies

Claims on a written contract, such as an individual disability policy bought outside work, generally carry a five-year limit in Florida. Policies can set their own timing rules, so read yours with a lawyer.

OFFSETS

Social Security can reduce your monthly benefit

Many long-term disability policies subtract Social Security disability payments. A retroactive SSDI award can trigger an overpayment demand from the insurer.

Before your first meeting

What to bring to a disability insurance consultation

0 of 6 ready

Methodology

How we chose these firms

We looked for Fort Lauderdale law firms that publish disability insurance work on their own websites and have a Google Business Profile with reviews. For each firm we compared its published practice areas, consultation terms and recent client reviews, and we note at least one limitation for every firm.

Disability Insurance Law Group appears first. The order is for presentation and is not an independently measured ranking.

Ratings, review counts and hours were checked on November 2, 2026.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a lawyer to appeal a denied long-term disability claim?

Not legally, but in an ERISA case the internal appeal often becomes the only record a court will review. Many claimants bring in a lawyer before the appeal is filed, not after.

How long do I have to appeal an ERISA disability denial?

Federal rules give at least 180 days from the denial letter to file the internal appeal. Check the exact deadline in your denial letter.

What is a disability insurance buyout?

A buyout is a lump sum the insurer offers in exchange for closing the claim and ending future monthly payments. Age, health outlook, taxes and the present value of future benefits all affect whether an offer is fair.

Can Social Security disability reduce my long-term disability check?

Often, yes. Many group policies subtract SSDI benefits, and a retroactive award can lead the insurer to demand repayment of an overpayment.

Which court hears a disability insurance lawsuit in Fort Lauderdale?

Claims under employer group policies governed by ERISA usually go to federal court; the Fort Lauderdale division sits at 299 E Broward Blvd. Individual policy disputes can be filed in Broward County court.

Where is Disability Insurance Law Group located?

The firm's office is at 3201 W Commercial Blvd, Suite 227, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33309. Its phone number is (954) 989-9000.

Who at Disability Insurance Law Group handles disability claims?

The firm's website lists attorneys Alicia Paulino Grisham and Mindy L. Chmielarz. Ask which attorney will handle your file day to day.

Does the order of this list mean one firm is better?

No. The order reflects the editorial arrangement of this page, not an independent score.

Local guide

Fort Lauderdale disability claim local guide

Which courthouse and Social Security office sit closest to each firm.

180 daysMinimum ERISA appeal window
2Courthouses listed
5 yearsFlorida limit on most written contract claims

What is near each firm

Disability Insurance Law Group

Cypress Creek area

NEAREST COURTHOUSE
  • U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida (Fort Lauderdale)
    299 E Broward Blvd, Fort Lauderdale
    5.4 mi
NEAREST SOCIAL SECURITY OFFICE
  • Social Security Administration office
    3201 W Commercial Blvd, Suite 100, Fort Lauderdale
    0.1 mi

Lawlor, White & Murphey

Davie Boulevard, southwest of downtown

NEAREST COURTHOUSE
  • Broward County Courthouse
    201 SE 6th St, Fort Lauderdale
    2.0 mi
NEAREST SOCIAL SECURITY OFFICE
  • Social Security Administration office
    3201 W Commercial Blvd, Suite 100, Fort Lauderdale
    5.6 mi

Victor Peña Law PLLC

Downtown, Broward Boulevard

NEAREST COURTHOUSE
  • U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida (Fort Lauderdale)
    299 E Broward Blvd, Fort Lauderdale
    0.2 mi
NEAREST SOCIAL SECURITY OFFICE
  • Social Security Administration office
    3201 W Commercial Blvd, Suite 100, Fort Lauderdale
    5.5 mi

Distances are straight-line estimates.

Fort Lauderdale courthouses for insurance cases

⚖U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida (Fort Lauderdale)Federal court for most ERISA disability lawsuits📍 299 E Broward Blvd, Fort Lauderdale
⚖Broward County CourthouseState court for many individual policy disputes📍 201 SE 6th St, Fort Lauderdale

Social Security field office

SSASocial Security Administration officeWeekdays 9am–4pm (per Google); SSDI applications and award letters📍 3201 W Commercial Blvd, Suite 100, Fort Lauderdale

Tips for a Fort Lauderdale disability claim

  • Request the claim file. Under ERISA you can ask the insurer for the documents it relied on, free of charge.
  • Do not sign a buyout quickly. A lump sum ends future payments; have the offer valued first.
  • Keep treating. Gaps in medical care are a common reason insurers give for ending benefits.
  • Answer insurer requests in writing. Keep copies of every form and note every call.

This page is general information, not legal advice. The order of firms is for presentation and is not an independently measured ranking. Ratings, reviews and hours checked on November 2, 2026. Phone hours shown are as listed on Google; office visits may be by appointment.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top